An examination of The Principles of Unarmed Combat, Second Edition (2025)
Imagine two fighters standing within striking distance. One moves forward. The other changes position, adjusts the distance and avoids the attack. To an observer, the exchange may appear simple: an attack has missed, and a defensive movement has succeeded. But what actually determined the outcome? The speed of the strike? The distance between the two fighters? Their balance, timing and position? Or the decisions that shaped the movement before either person made contact?
The visible technique is only part of the answer. Behind it lies a sequence of choices and changing conditions that can determine whether an action succeeds or fails.
This is the territory explored by Mark Jacobs in The Principles of Unarmed Combat. Rather than presenting another collection of techniques or arguing for the superiority of a particular martial arts tradition, Jacobs takes a broader approach. He examines the principles that govern unarmed combat across different systems, considering both sporting competition and self-defence.
The central question raised by the book is straightforward, but far-reaching: how can we understand what makes a technique effective without looking at the movement in isolation?
The second edition, published in 2025, provides an opportunity to examine how Jacobs has developed this approach and what his work offers to practitioners, instructors and readers interested in the mechanics of unarmed combat.
Beyond the catalogue of techniques
Jacobs is clear about the purpose of his book. In the introduction, he distinguishes it from a conventional martial arts manual. His intention is not to teach one particular system or promote a preferred style. Instead, he seeks to examine the principles underlying unarmed combat through what he describes as a rational and scientific approach.
That distinction gives the book its direction. Martial arts contain a wide range of technical traditions, each with its own terminology, training methods and explanations of movement. Techniques may look different from one discipline to another, but the problems practitioners face are often related: maintaining balance, controlling distance, creating an opportunity to attack, responding to an incoming strike and adapting when the situation changes.
Jacobs looks beneath these stylistic differences. His interest lies in identifying principles that can be examined across different forms of combat, rather than treating each system as an isolated body of knowledge.
The scope is deliberately broad. The book considers boxing, wrestling, kickboxing, grappling and other martial arts practices. At the same time, Jacobs establishes limits to his investigation. He concentrates on the technical aspects of unarmed combat and does not attempt to evaluate every traditional or philosophical concept associated with martial arts, particularly where he considers the scientific evidence insufficient for objective examination. Weapons remain largely outside the central scope of the work, although they are acknowledged in discussions of practical self-defence.
These boundaries are important. They clarify that the book is an analytical examination of unarmed combat, not an attempt to provide a complete theory of every aspect of martial arts.
The first question: what does winning actually mean?
The foundation of Jacobs’s approach is not a stance, a strike or a defensive movement. It is the definition of the objective.
The opening chapter considers a question that can easily be overlooked when combat is discussed primarily in technical terms: what does success actually mean?
The answer depends on the situation. In boxing, victory may come through a knockout, a technical stoppage, a decision or disqualification. Wrestling operates under different criteria. A police officer dealing with an unarmed suspect must consider legal and institutional restrictions that do not apply in the same way to a professional fighter. For an ordinary person facing an assault, success may mean escaping without injury rather than defeating the attacker.
These situations cannot be judged by a single definition of victory. The objective changes, and with it the criteria by which an action should be assessed.
Jacobs formulates his fundamental principle as achieving the goal by the easiest means possible. He does not use “easiest” simply to mean the least physically demanding option. His formulation takes into account the least effort, the least risk and the greatest assurance of success.
The choice of method depends on three factors: the individual’s own strengths and weaknesses, those of the opponent, and the circumstances of the encounter. Of these, only one’s own attributes can be fully controlled. Training can improve physical and technical capabilities, but it cannot eliminate uncertainty about another person or guarantee favourable conditions.
This changes the way a technique should be evaluated. A movement cannot be judged solely by its speed, power or visual complexity. Its value depends on what it is intended to achieve, the conditions in which it is used and the risks involved.
A strategy that promises a quick result may expose the practitioner to greater danger. A more cautious approach may reduce that risk but require more time and energy. The appropriate choice depends on the objective and the circumstances.
Here, Jacobs moves beyond a discussion of physical technique. He begins to treat unarmed combat as a problem of decision-making under changing conditions.
The body as a system of relationships
One of the most substantial sections of the book is devoted to posture.
Jacobs examines stance width and height, leading side, weight distribution, body angle, contact with the surface, upper-body posture, head position and hand position. These are familiar elements of martial arts training, but his approach is to consider how they influence one another.
A stance affects the way a person can move. Weight distribution influences which direction is more readily available. Body angle changes the relationship between the fighter and the opponent. The position of the hands and upper body must work with the lower-body posture rather than being treated as an independent detail.
Consider the simple example of a change in weight distribution. It may seem like a small adjustment, but it can affect the direction in which a fighter can move most readily and the time needed to initiate that movement. The significance of the adjustment therefore depends on the position of the opponent and the demands of the situation. A posture that is useful under one set of conditions may become a disadvantage when those conditions change.
The same analytical approach continues in the section on movement and footwork. Jacobs examines linear, lateral, diagonal and circular motion, together with pivoting, spinning, jumping, rolling and dropping movements. He also considers combinations of these forms.
The value of this classification is not simply that it provides a vocabulary for describing movement. It encourages the reader to ask what a particular movement makes possible, what it limits and how it changes the relationship between two opponents.
The book does not prescribe one universal stance or one ideal pattern of movement. Its emphasis is on the relationship between physical position and circumstances. Effectiveness, in this account, is conditional rather than absolute.

The difference between a technique and the way it is used
The discussion of striking offers one of the clearest examples of Jacobs’s analytical method.
In Chapter 22, Methods of Attack, he examines a classification associated with Bruce Lee and later expanded by Joe Lewis. Jacobs considers the expression “angles of attack” potentially confusing because it can suggest the physical direction from which a strike is delivered. He therefore uses the term “methods of attack” and develops the classification into nine categories:
- Direct Attack
- False Attack
- Combination Attack
- Disruption Attack
- Directional Attack
- Drawing Attack
- Change of Timing Attack
- Change of Target Attack
- Subterfuge Attack
The distinction is significant. It separates the physical technique from the method used to create the opportunity for that technique.
A punch or kick does not exist in isolation. The circumstances surrounding it may be just as important as the movement itself. An opponent may be induced to react, their position may be disrupted, their attention may be drawn elsewhere, or the timing and target may change. The technique is the visible action; the method of attack concerns how the opportunity for that action is created.
This is a more demanding way of looking at striking. Instead of asking only how a punch or kick is performed, the reader is encouraged to consider what happens before the technique is delivered and how the opponent’s response affects the available options.
Jacobs applies a similar interest in classification to defence. He devotes separate chapters to six principal methods of defending against strikes: distancing, avoiding, blocking, leading off, interrupting and smothering. Chapter 29, Last Ditch Defenses, deals separately with measures such as rolling with a blow, sacrificing non-vital targets and bracing oneself.
The distinction between these chapters matters. The six principal methods describe different ways of managing an incoming attack. The later chapter addresses situations in which a strike cannot be avoided or stopped by the usual means.
Taken together, these classifications present attack and defence not as isolated movements, but as ways of managing the changing relationship between two moving opponents.

The transitions between phases of combat
A further strength of the book is its attention to what happens when the distance between opponents changes.
The sections on entering, grabbing and clinching examine the transition from striking range to close contact. The subsequent discussion of takedowns distinguishes four broad categories: pain compliance, toppling, elevation and collapsing.

This material draws attention to a problem that can be overlooked when martial arts are divided into separate disciplines. A confrontation does not necessarily remain within one technical range. Standing combat may move into a clinch, the clinch may lead to a takedown, and the encounter may continue on the ground.
A practitioner can be proficient in one phase yet insufficiently prepared for the transition into another. The ability to strike does not automatically provide the ability to manage close contact or a change of level. Equally, technical knowledge of ground fighting does not remove the need to understand how the encounter reached that position.
Jacobs follows this progression into ground fighting, where he devotes considerable attention to positioning and control. He examines different positional relationships, including dominant face-to-face situations, foot and leg control, positions in which opponents face the same direction, and leg-to-leg situations. Submission holds and ground striking are treated as further elements of this phase.
Ground fighting is not presented as a brief appendix to standing combat. It receives sustained attention as a complex area in its own right.

The larger point is structural: unarmed combat is better understood as a connected field of actions and transitions than as a collection of techniques belonging to separate styles.
The uncomfortable questions: rules, consequences and the real world
The book also addresses subjects that are difficult to reconcile with the conventions of sporting competition.
Chapter 43, The Dark Side, examines foul tactics, including eye attacks, biting and groin attacks. Jacobs considers these actions in the context of the differences between sporting rules and situations in which a person genuinely fears serious harm. He also discusses the consequences of resorting to such tactics: the possibility of escalating violence, an opponent responding in kind, and the legal or sporting penalties that may follow.
The importance of this discussion lies not in treating prohibited actions as a technical catalogue, but in recognising that the circumstances of a confrontation affect the meaning and consequences of an action. What may be prohibited in a sporting environment cannot be assessed in exactly the same way as an action taken under the threat of serious harm. At the same time, the practical, legal and moral consequences do not disappear simply because a situation is dangerous.
Chapter 44, The Real World, continues the discussion through topics including avoiding trouble, alertness, retreat, confrontation, combat and legalities. Other chapters consider multiple opponents, obstacles, barriers and manoeuvring, as well as the relationship between strategies and styles.
These subjects reinforce a distinction that runs throughout the book: sporting competition and real-world self-defence do not necessarily share the same objectives, restrictions or risks.
A sporting match has rules and defined conditions. A real confrontation may involve uncertainty, environmental obstacles and legal consequences that cannot be reproduced simply by increasing the intensity of training.
Complexity in analysis, simplicity in action
Perhaps the most revealing chapter is Chapter 48, Simplicity.
After examining a wide range of variables, Jacobs arrives at an apparently paradoxical conclusion: combat is complex, but the way a person employs their skills should generally remain simple.
The distinction is between preparation and execution. Understanding the principles behind a technique can improve training and help a practitioner make better decisions over time. But an actual confrontation is unlikely to provide the opportunity to analyse every movement, calculate every variable and consciously select an optimal response.
Jacobs argues that the principles explored throughout the book are most useful when they have already been absorbed through training. Under pressure, a practitioner may not have time to reason through each decision. Familiarity with the principles may nevertheless help that person move towards a better course of action than they might otherwise have chosen.
This does not mean that complex techniques have no value. Rather, complexity should justify itself. A movement should not be considered superior merely because it is difficult, visually impressive or associated with a particular tradition. The relevant question is whether it offers a better way to achieve the objective under the circumstances.
The argument returns to the principle introduced at the beginning of the book: achieve the goal by the easiest means possible.
The analysis may be extensive. The action itself should not become unnecessarily complicated.
The psychological dimension
The final section, comprising three chapters, turns to the mental and emotional factors involved in combat.
Jacobs examines pre-fight psychology, the initial outbreak of combat and the psychological demands of the confrontation itself. Among the subjects covered are arousal, anxiety, confidence, fear, experience, training realism, startle responses, fight-or-flight reactions, concentration and perceptual narrowing.
The placement of this section is significant. After discussing posture, movement, striking, defence, transitions and ground fighting, the author returns to the person who must make those techniques work under pressure.
Technical ability alone does not guarantee effective performance. The psychological demands of a confrontation can affect how well a person applies skills developed through training. Jacobs therefore treats the mental and emotional dimensions not as an optional philosophical addition, but as part of the wider examination of combat performance.
His discussion also returns to the difference between sporting and self-defensive situations. The pressures, expectations and consequences may be very different, even when some of the physical actions appear similar.
Fifteen years later: a revised work, not a claim of perfection
The second edition gives the book an additional dimension.
In his 2025 preface, Jacobs explains that fifteen years have passed since the first edition was completed. During that period, he continued to train, write about and research martial arts, while collecting scientific studies relevant to the subject.
He writes that relatively little of the new information significantly contradicted the original work, but that the first edition could nevertheless be improved.
His formulation of this position is particularly revealing:
There is no perfect, only better.
It is more than a memorable line. It expresses the attitude behind the revised edition. Jacobs does not present the first version as a finished system that subsequent years merely confirmed. Nor does he claim that the new edition represents a final answer. Instead, he describes a work that can be developed as knowledge and experience accumulate.
The 2025 edition adds dozens of pages of new information, particularly in the sections on striking, ground fighting and miscellaneous topics. The author also explains that he retained more than 300 illustrations from the first edition. He notes that incorporating new images alongside the revised text proved too difficult and time-consuming.
These details clarify the nature of the revision. The second edition expands and develops the original work, but it does not claim to replace every element with newly produced material.
That approach is consistent with the book’s central premise: principles are useful not because they are beyond question, but because they provide a basis for continued examination and improvement.
A journalist examining the mechanics of combat
Jacobs’s professional background adds another dimension to the book.
According to the author’s biography, he began studying Goju karate as a child and later trained in boxing, kickboxing, shootfighting, the Gene LeBell grappling system, Filipino and Burmese martial arts, among other disciplines.
His professional writing career includes work for Sports Illustrated, Men’s Fitness and The Ring Magazine. He also served as a contributing editor and monthly columnist for Black Belt Magazine, contributed to Personal Defense World and hosts The Martial Podcast.
For a reader of World of Martial Arts, this background is relevant not simply as a list of credentials. Jacobs approaches his subject as someone with experience of martial arts practice and a professional history of writing about combat sports. The book brings together technical classifications, practical considerations and engagement with published research, while attempting to make a broad subject accessible through a consistent analytical framework.
Its ambition is considerable. Unarmed combat is a field in which technical traditions, individual experience and situational demands often intersect. Organising that material around principles rather than allegiance to a particular style is a challenging editorial and intellectual task.
The book does not eliminate disagreement between systems, nor does it establish a formula that guarantees success. Its contribution is to give readers a structured way of examining the relationship between objectives, physical actions, changing conditions and risk.
Learning to look beyond the movement
For readers of World of Martial Arts, one of the most useful ways to approach Jacobs’s work is to carry its central question beyond the pages of the book.
When examining a technique, it is worth asking what objective it is intended to achieve, under what conditions it is being used, what changes during its execution, what risks it creates and whether another method might achieve the same objective with less effort or exposure.
These questions are an editorial analytical tool developed by World of Martial Arts from the themes explored in Jacobs’s book; they are not presented as a separate classification created by the author. Their purpose is to help readers apply the book’s wider approach when examining different martial arts practices.
This is also where the distinction between technique and principle becomes most useful. A technique can be copied. Its underlying conditions are harder to recognise. To understand why a movement works, a practitioner must look at more than its outward form. The objective, the opponent’s position, the distance, the timing and the possible consequences all matter.
The Principles of Unarmed Combat is an ambitious attempt to organise a broad field of martial practice around precisely these questions. Its value lies less in offering a new collection of movements than in encouraging a more systematic examination of the movements, decisions and conditions that shape combat.
Jacobs does not claim that combat can be reduced to exact mathematics. The human factor remains unpredictable, and no classification can remove the need for experience, judgement or adaptation. His book is best understood as an analytical framework, not a guarantee of results.
Return to the two fighters at striking distance. The observer may still see an attack and a defensive movement. But now there are other things to look for: the objective, the distance, the position, the timing, the response and the risks created by each decision.
The movement has not changed. The way we understand it has.
That is the central value of looking beneath the technique.
Mark Jacobs, The Principles of Unarmed Combat, Second Edition, 2025. Independently published by the author.
Book: The Principles of Unarmed Combat — Mark Jacobs
Editorial illustration note: The four posters accompanying this article were created specifically for World of Martial Arts. They are original WOMA visual interpretations and are not reproductions of, or illustrations from, Mark Jacobs’s book. The book cover shown is the original cover supplied for this feature.




